Alleged Impostor in Torrent Tracker Lawsuit Faces Contempt Charges
Last year, filmmaker Matthew Schneider sought a DMCA subpoena through a California federal court, aiming to obtain information from Cloudflare about several private torrent trackers, including PassThePopcorn, BroadcasTheNet, Karagarga, HDBits, and Beyond-HD, which he alleged had shared his works without permission. However, the situation escalated when the same defendants were sued in an Illinois federal court, where evidence emerged suggesting that Schneider might not be who he claims to be. In a surprising twist, he dropped the lawsuit last month, but the case did not end there.
Judge Andrea R. Wood retained jurisdiction over the sanctions request, which hinges on verifying the identity of the plaintiff. During a September hearing, the individual asserting to be Matthew Schneider claimed that this is indeed his legal name and that he resides in London. The court responded by requesting official documentation to substantiate his claims.
Explore on Amazon
Amazon shopping links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
An October 2 status hearing was scheduled to take place via videoconference; however, the plaintiff joined by phone, citing technical difficulties. At this hearing, Judge Wood instructed him to email copies of his driver’s license, passport, and documentation from the U.S. Copyright Office by October 9. These documents were to be filed under seal and shared with the involved parties under a protective order. Yet, the deadline passed without any submission from the plaintiff.
On October 14, the plaintiff requested permission to present a single “independently certified and apostilled” UK government photo ID instead, arguing that UK data protection laws necessitate privacy restrictions. He contended that once his sensitive government ID is disclosed, the resulting loss of confidentiality cannot be undone. If the court does not agree to these restrictions, he has indicated he will seek an appellate review, although his motion did not address the Copyright Office records, which the defense claims have not been provided.
In response, Erin Russell, representing one of the defendants, urged Judge Wood to hold the plaintiff in civil contempt for failing to comply with the court's order to produce the necessary documents. Russell is not seeking punishment at this stage but rather a sworn statement detailing what was sent and when, followed by an in-person hearing.
Identity Verification and Discovery Delays
The question of the plaintiff’s identity is critical, as any potential sanctions against him would be uncollectible unless the court can confirm who he truly is. In a recent filing, Doe 1, one of the defendants, emphasized that the plaintiff’s refusal to produce his identification documents is obstructing the discovery process agreed upon by the parties. The filing suggests that this delay may not be accidental, hinting at a deliberate strategy by the plaintiff.
In the same filing, Doe 1 outlined proposed discovery requests and subpoenas, including requests for the plaintiff’s Gmail account information and billing records from his mailbox provider. The defendants are also seeking information related to the plaintiff’s access to court records, which they argue is necessary to establish his true identity.
Who Knew What
As the case continues to unfold, the implications of the plaintiff’s alleged deception remain significant. The defense is keen to establish the legitimacy of the claims made by Schneider, whose purported film production has already been called into question. They are requesting all materials related to his film, including raw footage and any AI-generated content, as they suspect the film may not be what it claims to be.
All parties are expected to meet again for a video hearing on November 17, where the court has instructed the plaintiff to ensure his video capabilities are functioning ahead of time. The outcome of this case could have lasting repercussions for all involved, particularly if the court finds the plaintiff has been less than forthcoming about his identity.




