Emotional Toll of Scams and Identity Theft Revealed in 2026 Report
Scams and identity theft inflict distinct but equally damaging effects on victims, as highlighted in the Identity Theft Resource Center's (ITRC) 2026 Consumer Impact Report. This report underscores that recovery from these incidents extends far beyond merely reclaiming lost funds. Victims of scams frequently endure feelings of shame and self-blame, while those affected by identity theft often invest significant time and effort to mend the damage done to their lives.
Conducted in August and September 2026, the ITRC's research surveyed 1,111 U.S. adults, alongside a separate group of 197 victims who sought assistance from the ITRC in the previous year. Eva Velasquez, CEO of the ITRC, stated, "Scams act as an acute trauma, while traditional identity theft acts as a chronic burden. Support for victims is as crucial now as it has ever been. Behind these numbers are real people enduring devastating trauma and shame. Lawmakers, companies, and technology leaders cannot treat this as business as usual."
Explore on Amazon
Amazon shopping links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Scams typically involve criminals manipulating victims into sending money or divulging personal information, while identity theft entails the outright theft of personal data for nefarious purposes. The two types of fraud can intersect when information obtained through a scam is later exploited to access accounts or commit further fraud.
Among the surveyed scam victims who reached out to the ITRC for help, a staggering 54.8% reported feelings of shame or embarrassment, with many expressing a belief that they bore some responsibility for the incident. The emotional fallout extended to sleep disturbances, as victims from both categories reported difficulties in falling or staying asleep.
Financial repercussions were significant, affecting working-age adults, including those from higher-income households. Some scam victims reported losses exceeding $100,000, with no recovery in sight. Seeking help proved challenging; 87.9% of scam victims indicated they had reached out to organizations for assistance but received no response. Many expressed that the organizations they contacted made them feel culpable for their situation.
The quest for assistance often led victims into further traps, with 78.9% of those surveyed paying fees to third parties promising recovery of stolen funds or credit repair. The ITRC identified these third-party services as recovery scams, which prey on the vulnerabilities of victims.
Victims' Struggles with Bureaucratic Indifference
One victim recounted their experience, saying, "The many people on the other end of the phone from various government entities really did not care about me and many gave the impression that I was the guilty party. There has been no resolution to my problem after 6 months."
Criminals frequently exploit stolen personal information to obtain credit, make unauthorized charges, open bank accounts, or misuse medical and employment records. Victims often find themselves ensnared in a bureaucratic labyrinth while trying to clear their names and regain control over their accounts.
Of the identity theft victims who contacted the ITRC, 64% reported spending over 40 hours trying to resolve the crime, with most indicating their cases remained unresolved at the time of the survey. Some victims discovered the crime long after it had occurred, further complicating their recovery efforts.
The repercussions of these scams and identity theft incidents extend into victims' professional lives as well. Many scam victims reported job losses, missed promotion opportunities, and strained relationships with supervisors due to the stress and fallout from these crimes.
Behind Closed Doors
Despite 91% of respondents claiming to be knowledgeable about protecting their personal information, nearly half admitted to having come close to sharing information or sending money in a scam within the past year. More than a quarter reported multiple close calls, highlighting the pervasive nature of these threats.
Respondents who successfully avoided scams often cited their instincts, familiarity with common tactics from consumer education, or warnings from banks or payment applications as key factors in their ability to evade fraud.




